« Finally Got Some New Work On The Go! | Main | Art vs Advertising »

It's Real!... no...wait,.. It's a Fake..... Ops.....hold on.... It's Real!

There seems to be a lot of news about fake Rembrandt paintings these days.  Back in January a Portuguese gallery discovered that two of its Rembrandt paintings were fake.  Yesterday I read that the  National Gallery in Copenhagen discovered that two paintings that they thought to be fake Rembrandt’s turn out to be in fact genuine. Last year I read how what was thought to be a fake Rembrandt had in fact been painted over  by another artist and the real painting lay underneath.

It amazes me how much energy goes into this.  A genuine Rembrandt is valued so highly that a lot of time and effort goes into figuring out which ones are real and which are fake.
It’s odd to see the work reduced to almost  black and white terms, real Rembrandt,. fake Rembrandt.  What’s even weirder in my mind is the way the work morphs from real to fake to real again, I mean for god sakes make up your mind!  How do you view such work?  Is the name attached to it the only thing that makes of breaks it? Maybe to the galleries involved this is nothing more than an exercise in an objects monetary value, who knows. It’s the conceptual shift in the viewer that interest me.  How does the viewer react when a work shifts from real to fake and then back again.  Is the work really seen all that differently?  Is the name really that important?

Posted on Friday, January 20, 2006 at 09:51AM by Registered CommenterHoward | Comments5 Comments

Reader Comments (5)

I think it's for the same reason that an authentic antique has more value than a modern version of an antique. There is all this mystique associated with the item being old, and touched by the master, handed down through the years, treasured. Something about a knock off takes all that away. And, the original rendering of the painting or idea gave it its true value, so, no matter how well an artist can render a masterpiece today, it's not the same thing. And, in terms of investments for museums etc. I guess it makes a huge deal considering the value. I know how I felt the first time I saw the "real" Mona Lisa...I doubt I would have felt any awe if I'd been told it was an exact replica of the Mona Lisa...it's purely psychological...people want to hold on to a bit of the past...connect with it, ya know?
January 23, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterElise
That's true. The funny thing here is that most of the fake Rembrandts are almost as old as the originals. Even though the work is fake it's still antique and some of the fakes are worth thousands of dollars in there own right.
January 23, 2006 | Registered CommenterHoward
Yah, I guess they'd have to be nearly as old in order to fool the tests they do on the paint etc. which does make it more confusing...and probably really frustrating for the curators, especially considering what "originals" go for.
January 25, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterElise
My mother recently purchased an oil on canvas painting that has Rembrandts name at bottom im sure it is not an original by him but is there a way to tell if it is worth anything and how can you tell if it is a copy or a painting by one of his students? appreciate all replies
October 18, 2006 | Unregistered Commenterdennis
You'd have to find someone qualified to appraise the work. It's not something I have any experience with.
October 19, 2006 | Registered CommenterHoward

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.